Federal prosecutors were directed by way of U.S. Lawyer Common Pam Bondi this week to pursue the loss of life penalty in opposition to Luigi Mangione, the person accused of murdering United Healthcare CEO Brian Thompson final yr in New York Town.
Mangione allegedly shot Thompson as the chief was once headed to a well being care convention on Dec. 4, killing the daddy of 2 in the street. The 26-year-old faces federal homicide and stalking fees and 11 state fees, together with homicide and terrorism fees, which don’t seem to be eligible for the loss of life penalty.
“After cautious attention, I’ve directed federal prosecutors to hunt the loss of life penalty on this case as we feature out President Trump’s schedule to prevent violent crime and Make The usa Protected Once more,” Bondi mentioned in a observation Tuesday.
Getty Photographs 
Mr. Trump signed an govt order on his first day in office directing the Division of Justice to hunt the loss of life penalty the place acceptable.
Lawyers for Luigi Mangione requested a pass judgement on to prevent federal prosecutors from in the hunt for the loss of life penalty in opposition to their consumer, announcing the U.S. executive “intends to kill Mr. Mangione as a political stunt.”
The movement filed 11 days after the loss of life penalty announcement within the U.S. District Court docket of the Southern District mentioned U.S. Lawyer Common Pam Bondi ordered the loss of life penalty to “perform President Trump’s schedule to prevent violent crime and Make The usa Protected Once more.”
“This transfer is one in a chain of strikes for the Trump management to ‘repair’ the federal loss of life penalty,” mentioned Corinna Barrett Lain, loss of life penalty knowledgeable and a legislation professor on the College of Richmond College of Regulation.
The Mangione case is the primary high-profile one to come back below his management’s directive, Lain mentioned; then again, the federal loss of life row panorama has modified dramatically since Mr. Trump’s first time period — and the urge for food for executions national has plummeted. In 2024, there have been 26 new loss of life sentences; in 2004, there have been 125, she mentioned.
New York State, the place Mangione is charged, abolished the loss of life penalty in 2007, consistent with the Demise Penalty Knowledge Heart, a not-for-profit group based totally in D.C. In keeping with their monitoring, even though there have been prisoners on New York’s loss of life row in 2007, an execution hasn’t taken position there since Eddie Mays in 1963.
Federal prosecutors would possibly in finding themselves in the similar scenario with Mangione, Lain mentioned, who has written a e-book on deadly injection, as it could possibly take a federal loss of life penalty case a minimum of twenty years to wind its means in the course of the felony machine.
What’s the federal loss of life penalty?
The federal loss of life penalty is in all 50 states and U.S. territories however is used relatively hardly ever in comparison to using capital punishment by way of states. How it’s carried out is determined by way of a coverage the U.S. Division of Justice has written in its justice handbook, Robin Maher, govt director of the Demise Knowledge Coverage Heart, instructed CBS Information.
The handbook main points how — or why — federal prosecutors make a decision to hunt a federal loss of life sentence, mentioned Maher.
“It isn’t transparent that that procedure has been adopted with admire to this choice to hunt loss of life for Mr. Mangione,” Maher mentioned.
The U.S. Division of Justice said the death penalty can most effective be imposed on defendants convicted of capital offenses, equivalent to homicide, treason, genocide, or the killing or kidnapping of a congressman, the president, or a Very best Court docket justice. Mr. Trump expanded the scope in his January executive order, announcing federal prosecutors will search the loss of life penalty “for essentially the most severe, readily provable offenses.”
Each and every case is authorized by way of the Division of Justice headquarters in Washington, D.C., in consultation with native U.S. Lawyer places of work, who prosecute the instances.
What’s a federal execution?
A number of federal loss of life sentences have been execseminimizeed in states that experience abolished the loss of life penalty, the Demise Knowledge Coverage Heart mentioned. Inmates who’ve gained a federal loss of life sentence are achieved on the federal loss of life chamber within the U.S. Jail Terre Haute in Indiana.
Maximum federal executions are performed by way of deadly injection — till 2020, it was once the only real means of execution. Strategies have been then expanded to incorporate ones authorized by way of the state wherein the federal loss of life sentence was once imposed. In some instances this might be by way of firing squad, such because the recent execution in South Carolina, or by way of nitrogen gas, which was once utilized in Alabama and Louisiana.
Between the reinstatement of the federal loss of life penalty in 1988 and 2024, 80 federal defendants were sentenced to loss of life and 16 have been exeminimizeed.
Underneath the primary Trump management, 13 folks have been achieved over 6 months in 2020-2021, DPI showed to CBS Information.
Who’s on federal loss of life row?
Federal loss of life row prisoners from everywhere the councheck out are housed within the Particular Confinement Unit at U.S. Jail Terre Haute in Indiana.
Many loss of life row inmates die from previous age, Lain mentioned, and lots of are by no means achieved. Instances can take a minimum of a decade to wind thru courtroom and hundreds of thousands of greenbacks to pass judgement on, “is that this a existence price saving?” mentioned Lain, who mentioned every loss of life row case has two trials, one for the crime and the opposite for sentencing. In impact, criminals are being sentenced to “existence with out parole with a random likelihood of execution,” and the federal government is paying hundreds of thousands for the prosecution, she mentioned.
There are 3 prisoners these days on federal loss of life row: Roberts Bowers, who was once convicted in 2023 for the mass shooting at Tree of Existence Synagogue; Dylann Roof, who was once convicted in 2017 for the deadly shooting of 9 parishioners in a Black church in Charleston, South Carolina; and Dzhokhar Tsarnaev for the 2015 Boston Marathon bombing.
Then-U.S. Lawyer Common Merrick Garland put a moratorium on federal executions in position in a while after taking place of work in order that an inside DOJ assessment of execution insurance policies and practices may happen, Maher mentioned. That moratorium on executions was once in position till the tip of the Biden management.
Former President Joe Biden commuted the death sentences of 37 out of 40 federal loss of life row prisoners to sentences of existence with out parole on Dec. 23, 2024, ahead of he left place of work.
